Dust to Dust: Redesigning Urban Life in Healthy Soils is an urban design ideas competition. We invite concepts for urban designs, planning approaches, and concrete interventions that could be implemented in real-life situations. Successful design ideas will be exhibited to inform and inspire greater sustainability in future urban design and development, accounting for a close relationship between urban life and soil ecosystem services.
Dust to Dust will operate as a charrette. Teams can apply by submitting an outline idea using this website to compete for a place on this intensive workshop. The following pages present precisely what we are looking for and what is involved.
We welcome applications of teams with outline ideas until
How can the future design and configuration of cities promote greater sustainability in the conditions of urban life? Dust to Dust challenges competitors to consider solutions beyond sociotechnological ’smart cities’ or the densification paradigm of ’compact cities’.
We welcome urban design ideas that revisit the basic entwined relationship between settled life, land, cultivation, and soil ecosystem services broadly conceived. Ideas that require ’thinking outside the box’ are especially welcome, as long as an awareness of potential towards implementation is demonstrated. What would incorporating soils in city design to ensure sustenance and ecosystemic resilience look like? When we give space to ecosystem dynamics, how would urban dispersal still allow effective urban life?
Outline plans could pursue an interventionist or a blue sky approach.
Detailed competition brief
Why have a competition on this particular challenge?
Currently 83% of the terrestrial biosphere is under human influence1 and 98% of cultivable land on earth is being farmed2. Two thirds of the world’s soils are already suffering a degree of degradation3. Meanwhile the expansion of urban land cover outpaces population growth. This expansion rate is unaffected by proximity to World Protected Areas. Such increase in the urbanisation of land, along rising populations and growing economic activity, is expected to sprawl built environment manifestations progressively4. This increases environmental vulnerability, fragments habitats, threatens biodiversity, and causes desertification5. The continued encroachment onto and the transformation of soils resulting from urban sprawl will significantly impact the sustainability and resilience of urban life. The urgency for design interventions to preserve and assist the formation of healthy soils within our cities is mounting. We cannot afford to continue to develop cities that compromise the ability of settled environments to provide the ecosystem services on which we depend.
New designs will need to promote innovative relations between everyday urban life, sustenance, and ecosystemic resilience. Such close relations demand that we consider integrating food production in built-up areas, that we leave open, or open up, surfaces to natural formation processes, that we account for how the materials associated with urban form and urban life decay, and that we keep blue-green space for ecosystem services accessible within our cities on a variety of private-to-public scales. This also concerns how we facilitate adjustments in our personal relations to ecosystem services. We must regard our social roles not as short (re)cycles, but as flexible and progressive processes in the long term.
We should foster the land we design and occupy so that we retain and improve the efficacy of soil benefits and accessibility in cities. How sustainable cities are designed needs to account fully for the fabric and social rhythms of the city and how these rhythms progress soil health.
Can a dispersed, less densely built-up or populated urban layout be as viable as one that is compact? The archaeology of Neotropical urbanism in the Americas is revealing alternative patterns of city building that have lived through long developmental histories. While we do not propose naively that ancient patterns are a solution for present-day predicaments, analysis of the long term history of these patterns makes it possible to imagine alternative dimensions.
What would a close relation to the role of soils in ensuring sustenance and ecosystemic resilience look like? If we allow for levels of density that gives more space to ecosystem dynamics, would this still result in effective patterns of occupation? How can dispersal maintain viable levels of social relations and productive intensity at the same time? Outline plans could either follow an interventionist or a blue sky/empty sheet approach. Proposals could consider, among others, low energy-intensity low-impact schemes, the promotion of natural material and naturally decomposing material requirements, the reinvention of vernacular practices, active travel, and the responsible integration of open space in everyday life.
What is Dust to Dust?
This presentation is a call for interdisciplinary and/or intersectoral urban design teams to submit outline plans for our urban design ideas competition. Outline ideas should be of excellent quality and demonstrably address the questions and challenges described in the call and brief on this website.
Only outline ideas are required for submission, because the Dust to Dust urban design ideas competition will be run as a charrette. This means that selected teams will be invited to participate in an intensive multiple day workshop with the interdisciplinary researchers who are organising this competition and the curating team that aims to exhibit the best ideas worked into plans for display.
The competition will run in three stages:
Call and selection of outline plans (until 23:59 GMT on 9th May 2018);
Charrette of selected teams with the interdisciplinary research and curating team 16-18 July 2018, at the Prince’s Foundation, London;
TruLife began in April 2016. Over the course of three academic workshops the themes of Decay & Waste Management, Spatial Practice, and Food Security were explored with the express aim of finding mutually beneficial synergies between the deep past of Maya tropical cities and the challenges of urban design for sustainable urban futures. TruLife activities have brought together 26 researchers from nine different countries spread over 21 different institutions. Among fields represented are urban design, architecture, Maya archaeology, ecology, industrial engineering, geography, soil science, and social sustainability. The group is now promoting research synergies that emerged from analysing Maya urban patterns and their potential to address sustainability challenges of urban design. With Dust to Dust we aim to apply insights gained during the workshops and urban design practice by developing and creating a platform for innovative, implementable ideas that are inspired by or translate this academic exchange.
Our partners at RIBA South/Southeast endorse and promote the Dust to Dust competition. We are currently working with the Sainsbury Centre for Visual Art (SCVA) to realise an exhibition of the best design ideas. The exhibition will combine artefacts from the Maya past with visions for the urban future at a world-renowned venue. Winning ideas will gain recognition and valuable public exposure.
How does Dust to Dust work?
Dust to Dust offers an excellent opportunity to explore and widely disseminate new ideas. For selected teams, the charrette is an opportunity to work on their outline ideas with capable research team members according to an innovative agenda. The charrette also offers a chance to exhibit these ideas at an internationally renowned venue.
Call for outline plans until 23:59 GMT on 9th May 2018;
Entrant’s registration fee payment deadline 23:59 GMT on 16th May 2018;
Interdisciplinary judging process (designers, policy, and research) May 2018;
Invitation for the charrette sent out by 5th June 2018;
Charrette workshop over several consecutive days in July 2018, hosted at the Prince’s Foundation, London, UK;
Development phase for final displays for exhibition, taking place over summer 2018;
Those invited to partake in the charrette will be eligible for bursaries to support attendance, but there are limitations to the total number of people per team and the amounts of support available.
Under usual circumstances we would expect two people to represent a design ideas team at the charrette.
Each team making a submission should pay the Entrant’s Registration fee through the University of Kent Online Store. The fee is 65GBP per team, or 40GBP for a student team. Please indicate your outline idea title and the main applicant’s email address when completing the payment. Payment can be made any time until 23:59 GMT on 16th May 2018.
Who can apply to Dust to Dust?
In principle, Dust to Dust: Redesigning Urban Life in Healthy Soils is open to everyone.
We ask, however, that candidates put together a convincing collaborative team. A delegation of selected teams is expected to be able to thrive in an open-minded, exploratory, and developmental environment and to work intensively towards outputs worthy of display in an exhibition.
We expect that architectural and urban design firms, young professionals in the commercial and public planning sector, individuals with a background as architects, town planners, civil engineers, or those with affiliate expertise, and students focused on these topics will be attracted by this brief.
What are the selection criteria?
Selection of outline ideas is first and foremost down to the vision and fit of how outline ideas respond to the call and brief of Dust to Dust: Redesigning Urban Life in Healthy Soils.
This list breaks down concrete criteria against which outline ideas will be judged:
Quality of design (sketches, visualisations, technical specifications) and supporting materials, including textual specifications, demonstrating the potential for excellent results in urban design or planning;
Demonstrating a progressive and original vision (incl. otherness or alternative conceptions of urban life), especially the way in which ideas move beyond the ’compact city’ and ’smart city’ paradigms;
The clarity and conviction, with appropriate supporting reference material or prospects, that motivate and concretise the probable benefits and functioning of outline proposals (e.g. with regards to soil formation, food production, ecosystem performance, effects of design and material decay, managing material flows/deposition in the city, dynamics of social life and accessibility, mechanisms for (social) resilience under stress, desirability of the experience of designs, participation in the human-nature relation, relation to deep history and effects in the archaeological long-term, etc.);
Credibility and interdisciplinary balance of expertise and/or sectors in teams. Please note that experience is no impediment to success. Credibility will be assessed using your supportive and motivational statement, explaining the roles and background knowledge of your team;
Articulation of the anticipated impact on urban life, including social practice and attitudes to urban habitat formation, and the role of soil ecosystem services, should the idea be implemented;
Potential and feasibility for implementation in planning and design practice.
Who will judge my work?
Which formats are accepted?
We want you to be creative.
Dust to Dust will not prescribe a format for outline ideas. As a design ideas competition, we expect at least some kind of visualisation or reification of your plans. This could still be at a preliminary stage, but should be sufficiently clear to be understandable as well as illustrative for judging. It is worth bearing in mind that outline ideas will be further developed, adapted, and finalised with input from the charrette. Nonetheless, we will need to see a clear rationale, a basic justification and motivation, to support and substantiate the idea(s) in text and visualisations.
This supportive and motivational statement should explain the kind(s) of problem(s) addressed, clarify the composition and expertise of the team, specify the compatibility with the brief, demonstrate the anticipated impact, and argue the feasibility of routes to and requirements for implementation.
Your ideas need to feel visionary and potentially real. We would normally expect outline submissions to be in a digital format, but please contact us if you are keen to submit in another format.
Submissions should normally not exceed the following limitations:
5 pages of 12pt text. (This should be your supportive and motivational statement. File size limit: 10MB. Preferred file types: PDF, DOC/DOCX.);
15 images. (Please submit images in a slideshow, with captions. This should include renders of any models. File size limit: 100MB. Preferred file types: PDF, PPT/PPTX, DOC/DOCX.);
3 minutes of video or animated material. (You can submit up to five files, max. 100MB each. Please consider restricting your bit rate for the purpose of making the submission.);
One file containing any reference(s) or reference materials as appendices to your application. (File size limit: 10MB).
Please note that the Outline Idea Submission Form will also require you to supply a title for your outline idea (character limit, incl. spaces: 350) and a description/abstract (character limit, incl. spaces: 1250).
NB the Outline Idea Submission Form is based on a free to use Google platform, which requires respondents to be logged into a Google account to fill out the form. Should you find yourself without, we suggest opening a Google account for the purpose of entering the competition.
Submit an idea
Please submit your outline ideas, using the dedicated form linked to on this webpage. For any queries, please contact us through the appropriate web form (please scroll down).
All submissions are welcome until 23:59 GMT on 9th May 2018.
Each team must complete the payment of the Entrant’s Registration fee until 23:59 GMT on 16th May 2018.
Judging by an expert team (see dedicated section above, TBC) will take place in May, and notification of selection for a place will be sent out by the 5th June 2018.
By using this website, participating in this competition, and making a submission, you (from here on “The User/s”, which includes all team members identified on a submission) are agreeing to accept our Terms and Conditions set out below.
A. Dust to Dust: Redesigning Urban Life in Healthy Soils is the name given to this competition by the research network Pre-Columbian Tropical Urban Life (TruLife): Placing the Past in Designs for more Sustainable Urban Futures. This research network is funded by the Arts and Humanities Research Council (AHRC) in the United Kingdom and hosted at the University of Kent by grant holder Benjamin Vis, sharing directorial responsibility with Christian Isendahl, University of Gothenburg. It receives additional support from partners mentioned on this website and reserves the right to collaborate with others.
B. The activities associated with Dust to Dust are operated on a Non-profit basis and Dust to Dust or TruLife hold no commercial interests. Any funds received are used fully to support the development and delivery of the activities associated with the Dust to Dust competition. It cannot be precluded that any affiliate individual, or organisation may indirectly benefit from association with Dust to Dust and its related activities. TruLife and the Dust to Dust competition remain independent from the interests of any supporting partner or sponsor.
C. Dust to Dust sets forth the following Terms and Conditions, which regulate the use of this website and the competition hosted on this website. The competition hosted on the Dust to Dust website is organised and administered by TruLife.
A. All information collected on the Dust to Dust website (www.dusttodustcompetition.co.uk) is only used to process and administer competition submissions in accordance with the competition’s Terms and Conditions.
3. Security Policy
A. All data entered by The User/s and collected through the website is collected, stored and processed through Dust to Dust’s data administration system provided by Google and subject to Google’s user policies and Terms and Conditions (https://www.google.com/policies/). TruLife and any organisation or individual involved in organising TruLife do not accept any responsibility or liability for the services provided by Google.
B. TruLife reserves the right to invite The User/s to submit data through alternative channels and to store data locally once received. This data is treated by TruLife and its affiliates with the utmost care and respect in accordance with the Data Protection Legislation.
A. TruLife reserves the right to amend these Terms and Conditions without prior notice. It is The User/s’ responsibility to ascertain regularly if any changes have been made to these Terms and Conditions, except when a submission has been made using this website, in which case those User/s shall be notified of any changes.
B. TruLife reserves the right to modify or withdraw any information provided on this website at any time without liability.
5. Trade Marks
A. All registered trademarks, symbols, or words are owned and protected property of the respective trademark owners.
6. Information Collection
A. The User/s’ personal information is collected by TruLife when The User/s make a submission to the competition or by using the Contact Us form. The following personal data is required to make a submission: all team members’ full name, country, telephone number, and email address. The following information is required to Contact Us: The User/s’ full name and email address. The User/s’ personal data is used only for communication and submission administration and processing regarding the competition. The contact details entered are only used to provide information and updates about the competition. If opted in, The User/s contact information may be used to inform The User/s about future competitions in accordance with the Data Protection Legislation.
C. TruLife reserves the right to monitor the activity and traffic patterns on this website to improve its functionality.
D. By submitting any data through Google services on this website, TruLife only becomes the owner of a copy of this data.
7. Liability indemnity
A. TruLife disclaims any liability for the contents of The User/s’ submissions and expressed opinions in relation any information provided on this Website, as well as opinions expressed or published about the Dust to Dust competition elsewhere.
B. By making a submission to the competition The User/s agree to release, discharge, and hold harmless TruLife (the organiser) and its partners, representatives, associates, and judges from any claims, losses, damages, expenses and liabilities (including attorney’s fees and settlement fees) arising out of their use of this website, participation, submission or any activities related to this competition.
C. By making a submission to the competition The User/s agree to release, discharge, and indemnify TruLife and its partners, representatives, associates, and judges from any claims, losses, damages, expenses and liabilities (including attorney’s fees and settlement fees) brought by any third party against TruLife due to or arising out of their submission, TruLife’s use of their submission or their participation in the competition, including claims for copyright and trademark infringement.
D. By making a submission to the competition The User/s agree that any disputes, claims, and causes of action between The User/s and TruLife (as the organiser) arising out of or connected with the competition or selection shall be resolved individually, without resort to any form of legal action or class action. In case of legal action or a claim brought by The User/s against TruLife or its agents The User/s shall pay TruLife or its agent’s attorneys’ fees and legal costs arising from the claim should it fail.
8. General Indemnity
A. The User/s agrees to indemnify TruLife from any liability and all claims, damages, losses, costs, expenses, and legal fees arising out of The User/s’ use of this website or a breach of these Terms and Conditions.
B. Only submissions for which a team member has paid the entrant’s registration fee before the payment deadline will be processed and pass through the competition’s selection process.
10. Governing Law
A. These Terms and Conditions are governed by the laws of England and Wales.
11. Information specific to organising the competition
A. TruLife reserves the right to assign judges, agents, or authorised other administrators to administer the Dust to Dust competition, including making any decision or exercising such decisions at its discretion.
B. TruLife reserves the right to create rules, which will apply to the Dust to Dust competition only.
C. By making a submission, The User/s agree to these Terms and Conditions and agree that all submissions adhere to these Terms and Conditions.
A. The Dust to Dust competition is open to anyone aged 18 and over. An individual aged over 18 years must represent any team members under 18 years of age.
B. TruLife members, members of the judging panel and their employees, or family members are prohibited from having their submission considered for the competition.
A. The User/s may make a submission as a team (at least two people).
B. Any submission made must be the original work of The User/s and must not have been previously published.
C. The User/s are prohibited from the sale, assignment, or transfer of any of the rights associated or resulting from their submission to a third party.
D. All Submissions must strictly conform to these Terms and Conditions and follow the submission guidelines, file restrictions, the guidance of the announcement, call, brief, and criteria, as stipulated by all information provided on this website and the Outline Idea Submission Form taken together.
E. Submissions to the competition should be made solely through the Outline Idea Submission Form via this website. This web form can be used upon logging in with a valid Google account (The User/s could set one up specifically for the purpose of entering this competition. Please ensure the Corresponding Applicant can be reached through the contact details provided.) Submissions received by email or any other delivery method will not be considered, unless previously agreed with TruLife by exception.
F. Only submissions made before the deadline as stipulated on this website can be considered for the competition.
14. Ensuring the integrity of the competition
A. Because the “credibility and balance of expertise and/or sectors in teams” is one of the selection criteria of the Dust to Dust competition and team composition needs to be addressed in the motivational and supportive statement, the anonymity of submissions cannot be ensured. Personal details (name and address) submitted in the Outline Idea Submission Form will not be forwarded to the judging panel, but team members’ affiliation and role/position will be. The User/s can still identify individuals in their submission data and materials.
B. Individual judges in the judging panel are obliged to make the other judging panel members aware when they suspect any conflict of interest that would affect their independent counsel regarding a submission. They will then exclude themselves from the judging process regarding that submission.
C. The judging panel will be made aware of The User/s identity after shortlisting and selection has been completed.
A. By making a submission to this competition, The User/s acknowledge and accept that all aspects of any submission may be used by TruLife, their associates, and any associates working with TruLife on the Dust to Dust competition, for publicity purposes.
B. Any publication, public display, or activities advertised on this website are not binding to TruLife as the organiser. TruLife shall make an effort to follow the announced schedule of activities, but cannot be held responsible for decisions made by partners regarding the support it receives and relies on and is further bound by funding restrictions.
16. Entrant Disqualification
A. Submissions that do not comply with the submission guidelines or contain any registered trademarks or designs shall be disqualified. TruLife is under no obligation to notify The User/s if their submission is disqualified.
B. Any submissions received after the submission deadline will be automatically disqualified.
C. Any submission for which the payment of the entrant’s registration fee is not received by the given deadline, will be removed from consideration in the competition.
D. No work previously submitted for the competition will be eligible for resubmission.
17. Cancellation of the Competition
A. TruLife reserves the right to cancel or suspend the competition or alter the competition rules at any stage, if in its opinion it is considered necessary, or if circumstances arise outside of its control.
18. Selection process
A. The judging panel’s decision is final. TruLife will not consider any appeals and TruLife nor its partners and associates shall enter into further correspondence about the result.
B. If a selected submission’s team cannot accept responsibility for selection, partake in the charrette, or becomes ineligible upon selection for any reason, the next highest ranking submission from the remaining shortlisted entries meeting the criteria shall be selected in its stead.
C. Unless explicitly specified TruLife’s association with the competition judges is not legally binding and does not imply any contract. Some judges on the judging panel have been previously associated with TruLife as a research network since its inception in April 2016.
19. Benefits of selection
A. All benefits associated with participation and selection in the Dust to Dust competition are stipulated on this website and can be subject to change or withdrawal without prior notice should TruLife deem it necessary to make changes for any reason within or without its direct control.
B. Selection of any submission does not imply any pathway to future realisation or financial investment in the idea or its feasibility. Urban design ideas for the purposes of the Dust to Dust competition, remain entirely hypothetical.
20. Publicity and promotion
A. TruLife can request any team member associated with The User/s’ submissions to participate in promotional and publicity arrangements, activities, and output in respect to the Dust to Dust competition. TruLife is authorised to use all statements made within any submission in connection with the Dust to Dust competition without additional approval.
21. Intellectual property right and copyright
A. Intellectual property rights, including copyright of the Dust to Dust website and competition belong to its author: here TruLife.
B. The User/s shall not receive or be entitled to receive any payment in any form for any submission made or for granting TruLife the right of using any data pertaining to the submission.
C. Intellectual property rights of all works submitted to the competition will be retained by The User/s, but it is a condition of entry that The User/s agree unconditionally to grant TruLife an unrestricted, worldwide, irrevocable and royalty-free license (but not the obligation) to use their submissions and reproduce any works as follows: publicly display by any means and in any media now and hereafter known, copy, modify, translate and/or adapt, archive and distribute in relation to competitions and publicity purposes without any further notice or remuneration to The User/s.
D. By making a submission to the Dust to Dust competition, The User/s grant TruLife an unrestricted, worldwide, irrevocable and royalty-free license (but not the obligation) to use their submission as follows: publicity displays, marketing, promotion, merchandise, discussion and education by any means and in any media now and hereafter known, copy, modify, translate and/or adapt, archive and distribute in relation to competitions and publicity purposes and may sub-license these specific, limited rights to others only for the same purposes, without any further notice or remuneration to The User/s.
E. The User/s reserve an equal right to publish, reproduce, and use their work (the data pertaining to the submission) without limitation.
F. All credits related to the data pertaining to each submission are associated with the respective author (The User/s can stipulate what name the work is credited to). TruLife shall (but is not obliged to) make a reasonable effort to display the author's name on any submission data or material whenever published or otherwise featured.
22. Information on content
A. The content this website provides is based on original research and research activities employed by TruLife, and, where cited, based on additional research sources.
B. The background image used on this website was published under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license by Andresnavarroforever, at: Wikimedia Commons.